2010 AFL Phanton Brownlow Medal - Leaderboard

[adam]

For everyone who has been following my 2010 Phantom Brownlow Medal, or for those who haven't, below are all the links you require to go back and read the season to date so far.

By clicking the "Review" link you'll get a full run down of each game including why I gave votes to specific players. By clicking the "Stats" link you'll get taken through to a list of the games from that round which includes player stats etc, which may be a useful guide for analysing games.

If anyone has any questions or input, then id be happy to answer any of your questions here

2010 Phantom Brownlow
Round 1	Review	Stats
Round 2	Review	Stats
Round 3	Review	Stats
Round 4	Review	Stats
Round 5	Review	Stats
Round 6	Review	Stats
Round 7	Review	Stats
Round 8	Review	Stats
Round 9	Review	Stats
Round 10	Review	Stats
Round 11	Review	Stats
Round 12	Review	Stats
Round 13	Review	Stats
Round 14	Review	Stats
Round 15	Review	Stats
Round 16	Review	Stats
Round 17	Review	Stats
Round 18	Review	Stats
Round 19	Review	Stats
Round 20	Review	Stats
Round 21	Review	Stats
Round 22	Review	Stats

Click here to view the Full Leaderboard at official Phantom Brownlow site

[adam]

For those new to our Phantom Brownlow Medal, basically we review every game of the season and give votes accordingly based on a 3-2-1 system.

We analyse many different things to come up with our votes which include watching the games, reading media opinions, taking into account players previous records in the Brownlow, among other things.

The system has been successful in the past, picking the top three last year as well as some other good value winners from Team Highest Vote Pollers, which you can bet on at Centrebet. The following links may be of some use.

• Official Phantom Brownlow Site
• Phantom Brownlow Reviews
• Sportsbet Brownlow Medal Market

[Punter]

I agree with most of your votes Adam but some of them I just don't see those players getting a vote eg. In round 4,Melbourne smashed Richmond and you gave Kelvin Moore 1 vote and no votes to Sylvia or green who kicked 5 and 4 goals respectively.I just can't see that happening especially when they got smashed.historically teams who get thumped,players don't poll from that losing side...don't get me wrong tho,you've done a great job for most of the games!

[gotheswans]

Hey Adam nice job with the site. Mate you have dane swan polling 30 at the moment which i think is way too high mate ablett polled 30 last year and swan has not had a year like ablett did last year ive got swan currently on 24. Other notable ones are Cooney polling ahead of boyd i have it the other way around. Andrew Swallow on 12 i think is way too high ive currently got him on 4 these are just a few i would advise you to have a look i have completed the brownlow form for last 5 years and have been very successful.

[adam]

Hey Adam nice job with the site. Mate you have dane swan polling 30 at the moment which i think is way too high mate ablett polled 30 last year and swan has not had a year like ablett did last year ive got swan currently on 24. Other notable ones are Cooney polling ahead of boyd i have it the other way around. Andrew Swallow on 12 i think is way too high ive currently got him on 4 these are just a few i would advise you to have a look i have completed the brownlow form for last 5 years and have been very successful.

Thanks for the feedback

All interesting points. I really think Swan has had a blinder of a year, even better than Ablett's last year, i can really see him polling a lot this year. Swallow has had a ripper of a year, whether the umpires agree with me remains to be seen, but i think he is a big chance of getting double figures.

If you have your count handy, would you mind pasting in here for us to have a look. Always interested in having a look at others counts, they can often vary so much, so always interesting o see it from others point of view.

Also, check out the Brownlow Medal Comp we have running here on the forum. Sound like it would be up your alley

[Punter]

Hey Adam nice job with the site. Mate you have dane swan polling 30 at the moment which i think is way too high mate ablett polled 30 last year and swan has not had a year like ablett did last year ive got swan currently on 24. Other notable ones are Cooney polling ahead of boyd i have it the other way around. Andrew Swallow on 12 i think is way too high ive currently got him on 4 these are just a few i would advise you to have a look i have completed the brownlow form for last 5 years and have been very successful.

Any chance of letting us know who you think will poll the most for each club?Would be interesting to see!

[adam]

Any chance of letting us know who you think will poll the most for each club?Would be interesting to see!

Definitely, will look into it mate

[gotheswans]

Hey Adam just having another look and noticed you only have alan didak polling 9 votes i have him alot higher close to 18 votes a couple rounds you should look at are round 4 round 11 round 14 round 16 and round 18 these rounds you did not give him a vote and i think he will poll in just about every game.also have an idea for you if intrested too hear in doing the votes aswell mate how do you currently do it urself and what sources do you use ???????

[adam]

Hey Adam just having another look and noticed you only have alan didak polling 9 votes i have him alot higher close to 18 votes a couple rounds you should look at are round 4 round 11 round 14 round 16 and round 18 these rounds you did not give him a vote and i think he will poll in just about every game.also have an idea for you if intrested too hear in doing the votes aswell mate how do you currently do it urself and what sources do you use ???????

I use a few sources for my votes, firstly i watch alot of games so i use my opinion as one of the main basis, but i also take close notice of media votes like Herald Sun, The Age and radio votes after game etc. I also scour other websites and check out other similar kinds of 'Phantom Brownlows' if you will, and if there is a real strong consensus for certain players in each game ill go with them.

I used a similar concept last year and did very well, but obviously had several players polling way more (or less) than real life, but thats just the nature of these things, as the umpires can get it wrong too which makes our mission even harder.

Definitely keen to hear the idea you have in mind

[adam]

For those who are reading this thread for the first time, or for those who don't already know about our Brownlow Medal Tipping competition which has just opened here at our forum, be sure to check it out.

There are some pretty cool prizes to be given away with the winenr receiving an iPod Touch, while second and third get a $150 and $100 Free Bet courtesy of our sponsors Centrebet.

It's free to enter and all you need to do is tip the first five vote pollers in order (as well as the votes) and the person who gets the closest is the winner. Check out the link below for the full details of how to join.

• Brownlow Medal Tipping Details